Newsletter 165

Monday 16 November 2026

Dear Subscriber,

Hope you had a great weekend. Please see below for the question, the answer to the previous question and associated resources. You can view a web version of this newsletter by clicking here.

Livestream!Join me live this Wednesday at 1pm for FLK2 Land and Property Law MCQs

Last call for our NOVEMBER SUPER SESSION: I will be holding another live SQE Super Session on 21 November. 30 Places available upon application. Topic is Dispute Resolution. If you would like to join, email me asap on events@glintiss.co.uk . Further info on events.dryannis.co.uk

This Week’s Question: A solicitor acts for a company purchasing commercial premises for £620,000. Shortly before completion, the solicitor discovers that a substantial part of the purchase funds originated from an unexplained third-party account. Following enquiries, the solicitor suspects that the funds constitute criminal property and reports the matter to the firm’s nominated officer. On Monday 5 October 2026, the nominated officer submits a valid suspicious activity report (SAR) to the National Crime Agency (NCA), requesting a defence against money laundering (DAML) for the proposed transfer of funds to the seller. On Monday 12 October, the NCA refuses the request. The NCA has made no subsequent application to extend the statutory moratorium, and no freezing order has been obtained. The client, who has not been informed about the SAR, insists that completion must take place on Monday 9 November 2026 to avoid substantial contractual penalties. No new information has emerged to resolve the original suspicion. Which of the following best describes whether the solicitor may proceed with completion on 9 November?

A. The solicitor may proceed because more than 31 calendar days have elapsed since the SAR was submitted and no court order has been obtained.

B. The solicitor may proceed because the seven-working-day notice period has expired, notwithstanding the NCA’s refusal during that period.

C. The solicitor must suspend all work on the transaction, including administrative preparation, until the NCA expressly confirms that its investigation has ended.

D. The solicitor must not complete because the 31-calendar-day moratorium runs from the NCA’s refusal, and that period has not yet expired.

E. The solicitor may proceed if the client provides an indemnity against any criminal liability arising from the transfer of the purchase funds.

Dig Deeper: Want to revise Legal Services?  Watch my new “100% human” video on https://youtu.be/N0oey3xd_Yc

Exclusive Subscriber Offers:

1) Missed one of my Super Sessions? Get the Digital Packs here, and don’t forget, YT Prepper and Substack members get £5 off (contact me for the discount code, or look in the YouTube community posts).

2) Use code “REVSQE10” for 10% off all ReviseSQE products (including bundles) and free p&p for printed resources when purchasing directly at their shop.

3) Use code “IOANNIS” to get 10% off any plan on Law Drills at https://www.practiceworks.io/lawdrills/

4) Need help working out why you are getting MCQs wrong? Try my free Mistake Lab! A new tool to help you spot areas you need to prioritise in your revision https://labs.dryannis.co.uk/

Last Week’s Question: A government department employs civil servants responsible for protecting critical national infrastructure against cyberattacks. Following a security review, the department introduces a policy prohibiting all employees from belonging to any trade union. The policy applies equally to employees who handle classified intelligence and administrative staff who have no access to sensitive information. The department relies on legislation permitting restrictions on employees’ activities where necessary to protect national security. It argues that union membership could create divided loyalties and increase the risk of confidential information being disclosed. However, there is no evidence that any union has compromised security, and the department has not considered less restrictive measures, such as confidentiality obligations or restrictions applying only to particular sensitive roles. Several employees seek legal advice about challenging the policy under the Human Rights Act 1998. Which of the following best describes their legal position?

A. The prohibition is automatically lawful because national security is expressly recognised as a justification for restricting freedom of association.

B. Article 11 provides an absolute right to trade union membership, so a prohibition affecting civil servants can never be legally justified.

C. The prohibition is necessarily unlawful because any restriction affecting trade union membership requires prior consultation with the employees concerned.

D. Article 11 does not protect civil servants working in national-security departments because members of the administration of the state are excluded from its scope.

E. Article 11 permits lawful restrictions for national-security purposes, but the department must justify the blanket prohibition as necessary and proportionate.

Correct answer: E. Article 11 permits lawful restrictions for national-security purposes, but the department must justify the blanket prohibition as necessary and proportionate. Feedback: Article 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights, incorporated into domestic law through Schedule 1 to the Human Rights Act 1998, protects freedom of peaceful assembly and association, including the right to form and join trade unions. However, Article 11 is a qualified right. Under Article 11(2), restrictions may be permitted where they are prescribed by law, pursue a legitimate objective such as national security, and are necessary and proportionate in a democratic society. The provision also expressly permits lawful restrictions for members of the armed forces, police and administration of the state. Section 6 Human Rights Act 1998 generally makes it unlawful for a public authority to act incompatibly with a Convention right, subject to the statutory exceptions concerning primary legislation.

A is wrong because national security is a recognised legitimate aim, but invoking it does not automatically make every restriction lawful. The government must justify the restriction. Applying an indiscriminate prohibition to employees without access to sensitive information raises significant questions about necessity and proportionality.

B is wrong because Article 11 is not an absolute right. Although it expressly protects trade union membership, Article 11(2) allows restrictions in specified circumstances. Candidates must distinguish absolute Convention rights from qualified rights.

C is wrong because prior consultation is not an express, universal legal prerequisite for restricting Article 11 rights. Consultation may be relevant when assessing procedural fairness or proportionality, but its absence does not automatically invalidate every restriction.

D is wrong because civil servants do not fall outside Article 11 altogether. The Convention expressly contemplates lawful restrictions affecting members of the administration of the state. This is a power to restrict the exercise of the right in appropriate circumstances, not a wholesale exclusion from its protection.

SQE1 examination point: The difficulty lies in recognising the distinction between a legitimate reason for restricting a Convention right and a legally justified restriction. Article 11(2) provides the essential framework: lawful basis, legitimate aim, necessity and proportionality. National security may justify restrictions, but it does not automatically validate their scope.

Thank you for subscribing and let me know how you are getting on in your preparation on Reddit! Feel free to forward this email to anyone you think will benefit.

If you wish to unsubscribe: You can stop receiving the newsletter at any time by emailing us at newsletter@glintiss.co.uk with ‘unsubscribe’ as the subject. We will promptly remove your email address from our mailing list. Thank you for being with us.

You will hear from me again soon.

All the best

Dr Ioannis (Yannis) Glinavos

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Cookie Consent with Real Cookie Banner